After that vet visit, I bought a glossy bottle of fish oil and thought I'd done the right thing. There were three problems I didn't understand at the time.
1. "Fish oil" is not the same as EPA and DHA. The big number on the front — 1,000mg salmon oil, omega-3 blend — isn't the number that matters. What matters is how much active EPA and DHA your cat actually gets per serve. On a lot of bottles, that figure is buried on the back and far smaller than the front implies. For brain support, the real question isn't "is this fish oil?" It's "how much DHA is my cat getting today?"
2. The moment you open the bottle, it starts going off. Omega-3s and oxygen don't mix. Every dropper, every pump, every reopen lets more air in, and the oil begins to oxidise. You might not smell it. Your cat will — their nose is far sharper than ours. It's the classic pattern: they eat it happily for a week, then suddenly refuse. The owner blames the cat. Often the cat is simply smelling oil that's turned — and once a cat refuses something, good luck winning them back.
3. The daily routine collapses. This was the real one for me. You can buy the best oil on earth, but if your cat licks around it, spills it, or only eats half the bowl, the routine fails. Some days too much, some days too little, some days nothing at all. For brain support, "sometimes" isn't good enough — the entire point is daily.
That's what made me switch.